650 Poydras Street, Suite 2300, New Orleans, LA 70130

Our lawyers at Favret Carriere Cronvich are determined to educate our clients on any issues that may concern them. We are dedicated to doing the work and research to stay up to date on any pressing and breaking legal matters.

Dealing with a Staged Car Accident

Dealing with a Staged Car Accident: Here’s What to Know

Car accidents are difficult. Learning that you were part of a planned accident makes it even more complicated and unfair. Staged car accidents, where individuals deliberately cause collisions to commit insurance fraud, can have serious consequences for innocent victims. This article discusses staged car accidents in Louisiana and offers advice for victims of this fraudulent scheme. 

Staged car accidents have been a known thing for decades. A simple google search using the search terms staged car accidents and insurance fraud will provide you with a multitude of articles.  

The persons involved in the fraud is rampant. From lawyers, doctors, insurance adjusters and participants. Even cases exist where family members recruit family to participate in such crimes. 

Insurance is necessary to compensate those genuinely injured in a car accident. To keep insurance programs solvent and accessible for drivers, we must fully punish fraud. 


The Web of Deceit: Understanding Staged Car Accidents 

Fraudsters plan fake car accidents to make false insurance claims and commit insurance fraud. Understanding the elements of these deceptive acts can help innocent victims recognize the signs: 

  1. The Swoop and Squat: In this scheme, one vehicle cuts in front of the victim’s vehicle and suddenly slams on the brakes, causing a rear-end collision. 
  2. The Drive Down: In a drive-down scenario, the fraudster waves the victim into traffic and then crashes into them, claiming that the victim failed to yield. 
  3. The T-Bone Trap: In this scheme, the fraudster intentionally speeds through a red light or stop sign, causing a collision with the victim’s vehicle. 
  4. Phantom Accidents: In some cases, staged accidents involve entirely fake accidents with no other vehicles involved. Fraudsters simply make claims for injuries and damages. 

How to deal with a staged car accident

Recognizing the Signs: How to Identify Staged Car Accidents 

Spotting a fake car accident is challenging because scammers try exceedingly hard to make it look authentic. However, there are several signs and red flags that may indicate a staged accident. If you notice any of these warning signs, proceed with caution and consider taking appropriate actions: 

  1. Unusual Behavior at the Scene:The other driver appears overly aggressive, agitated, or confrontational. They try to discourage you from calling the police or insist on handling the matter privately.
  2. Conflicting Stories: The accounts of the accident provided by the other driver, passengers, and witnesses don’t match. The story changes or becomes more elaborate over time.
  3. Lack of Cooperation: The other driver is hesitant to share insurance information or provide contact details. They resist involving law enforcement or refuse to call the police. 
  4. Minimal Vehicle Damage: The vehicle damage seems inconsistent with the reported severity of the accident. Damage appears staged, such as pre-existing damage being attributed to the accident.
  5. Exaggerated Injuries: The other driver and passengers claim severe injuries that seem disproportionate to the impact. They have a history of filing personal injury claims from previous accidents. 
  6. Phantom Vehicles: There were no independent witnesses to the accident, and the only witnesses are occupants of the other vehicle(s). You can’t find any witnesses or other vehicles involved in the accident. 
  7. Witness Statements Don’t Add Up: If there are independent witnesses, their statements contradict the version of events presented by the other driver. 
  8. Quick Settlement Offers: The other party or their representatives pressure you into accepting a quick settlement or cash payment to avoid involving insurance companies or law enforcement. 
  9. Multiple Claims: You discover that the other driver has a history of filing insurance claims for similar accidents or injuries. 
  10. No Police Report: The other driver resists calling the police, and they do not generate an official accident report. 
  11. Inconsistent Damage Patterns: Damage to the vehicles involved doesn’t align with the typical damage patterns seen in accidents. 
  12. Witness to Previous Accidents: You learn that the other driver or their passengers have previously participated in staged accidents. 


Taking Action: What to Do If You Suspect a Staged Car Accident 

If you believe you were the victim of a staged car accident, taking the right actions is crucial to protect your rights, gather evidence, and ensure a fair resolution. Here are the steps you should consider taking: 

  1. Ensure Safety: First, make sure you and your passengers are safe. Move your vehicle to a safe place if you can and get medical help if necessary. 
  2. Contact the Police: Call the police to report the accident and request an officer to come to the scene. A police report is an essential piece of evidence and can help document the circumstances of the accident. 
  3. Gather Evidence: Collect as much evidence as possible at the scene. This may include: 
  4. Photographs: Take pictures of the accident scene, including vehicle damage, license plates, road conditions, and any visible injuries. 
  5. Witness Information: Get the names and contact information of any witnesses. Their statements can be crucial in determining fault. 
  6. Exchange Information: Exchange contact, insurance, and driver’s license information with the other party involved in the accident, even if you suspect fraud. Do not admit fault or apologize. 
  7. Note Details: Note down accident details: date, time, location, weather, and other driver’s behavior.
  8. Do Not Discuss Fault: Avoid discussing fault or making statements about the accident with anyone other than the police and your insurance company. Be cautious about sharing details on social media. 
  9. Seek Medical Attention: Even if you don’t initially feel injured, it’s essential to see a healthcare professional promptly. Injuries may not immediately appear. Therefore, a doctor can examine for injuries to establish a connection between them and the accident. 
  10. Notify Your Insurance Company: Contact your insurance company as soon as possible to report the accident. Provide factual information about the accident but avoid making assumptions or accusations. 
  11. Consult an Attorney: Consider consulting an experienced personal injury attorney, especially if you suspect fraud or if you’ve sustained injuries. An attorney can help you navigate the legal process, protect your rights, and gather evidence. 
  12. Preserve Evidence: Keep all evidence related to the accident, including photographs, medical records, police reports, and any correspondence with insurance companies. 
  13. Cooperate with Authorities: If law enforcement or your insurance company launches an investigation into potential fraud, cooperate fully. Provide any requested information or statements truthfully. 
  14. Document Expenses: Save all receipts for accident expenses, like medical bills, car repairs, and other costs you paid for. 
  15. Be Patient: Investigating staged accidents can be complex and may take time. Be patient and allow the authorities and your attorney to handle the case. 
  16. Stay Informed: Keep yourself informed about the progress of the investigation and any legal proceedings. Your attorney should provide updates on your case. 

What to do if you suspect a staged car accident

The Legal Battle: Pursuing Justice in Staged Car Accident Cases  

Bringing those responsible for the staged accident to justice can be challenging, but it’s essential to protect your rights and deter future fraud. Here are potential legal actions: 

  1. Civil Lawsuit: You can file a civil lawsuit against the at-fault party for damages. Your attorney will gather evidence and build a case. 
  2. Insurance Investigation: Your insurance company may conduct its own investigation to uncover fraud and deny fraudulent claims. 
  3. Criminal Charges: If law enforcement suspects fraud, they may pursue criminal charges against the fraudsters. 
  4. Cooperate with Authorities: Be prepared to cooperate with investigators, provide testimony, and share evidence. 


Conclusion: Navigating the Maze of Staged Car Accidents in Louisiana 

Fake car accidents are dishonest and unfair, but victims can find justice and defend their rights with awareness and legal help. The law in Louisiana and elsewhere protects the innocent, and authorities can punish severely those who cause fake accidents. Recognize signs, take action, seek legal help. Victims can deal with staged car accidents and hold fraudsters accountable. 



Call 504-383-8978 for a FREE 15 minute consultation, or fill out form